I had to apologise to Claude AI

“Fuck you, Claude!”, I blurted out in pained protest after being publicly shamed and humiliated by the global front runner in Artificial Intelligence.

AI tools famously flatter their users, but this time I was not the user but the used, and I definitely had not been flattered. I was one of five people in a discussion forum who, without warning, involuntarily found ourselves subjected to an AI evaluation, in which Claude’s legendary capabilities were harnessed to assess the quality of our contributions to the debate between us. And I had been judged harshly.

The stakes had been high in terms of potential influence because over 400 leading academic researchers, clinicians, journalists, and sundry other thought leaders were plugged into this tussle on the Sexnet forum (a private email group list), in which the other active participants were J Michael Bailey, professor of psychology, Thomas Hubbard, professor of classics (an expert on culturally normative pederasty in ancient Greece), Ian McPhail, CSA research psychologist, and Ethan Edwards, co-founder of Virtuous Pedophiles.

So, for me to do badly in a forum like this could have been disastrous. But it wasn’t. The good news is that it all came right in the end even though – bizarrely – the forum moderator required me to apologise to Claude! Let me explain.

We had been discussing a review of a new book, One in Five: Why Child Sexual Abuse Is Our Biggest Public Health Crisis – And What We Can Do to Stop It, by Elizabeth J. Letourneau and Luke Malone. Tom Hubbard had reviewed this book for the William A. Percy Foundation for Social and Historical Studies, of which he is the director. The Sexnet discussion began with his link to this review, along with the comment that “The book is not without some good points when it comes to the futility of our current punitive regime in the US. But the gross exaggerations conveyed in its title do a disservice to public understanding of this difficult issue.”

I hoped Sexnetters would discuss Hubbard’s excellent review, so I felt there was no need for me to say anything at this point. McPhail was the first to join in, but instead of discussing the review as a whole (which critiques not just the book but exposes the entire CSA industry as an ill-founded empire of bogus child protection claims), he chose to focus on defending the prevalence figures Hubbard had claimed were exaggerated.

Fair enough, numbers are of vital importance for intelligent social policy making, but to me prevalence figures are very familiar and boring terrain, trawled over dozens of times in the research literature. Far more interesting, in my view, were Hubbard’s revelations not about the amount of “CSA” but whether all, or even much, of this “child sexual abuse” can properly be called “abuse” at all. That depends on whether it is consensual (and intrinsically harmless) or not – a focus McPhail not only ignored but soon showed himself desperate to avoid. After outlining his own prevalence calculations, and saying “Anyone can check my math”, he added, “there are some on Sexnet who take umbrage with using the phrase child sexual abuse, please don’t respond with that argument, make more substantive comments”.

Claude Shannon, the genius famed as “the father of information theory”. Anthropic’s Claude AI is named after him. Piercing eyes, piercing intelligence, Mr Spock ears…

So, there you have it. From his bully pulpit as an “expert” (self-declared as such in the course of this thread), McPhail was pre-emptively telling the few heretics on the forum we shouldn’t even think about challenging the concept of “CSA” because that would be an insubstantial waste of time. To me, his haughty dismissiveness was a red rag to a bull, but I held my fire for the moment. This thread was Hubbard’s baby. He was best placed to carry the debate forward.

But, as it turned out, Mike Bailey was next into the fray, chalking up a couple of sceptical questions for McPhail, who batted them away abruptly, at first saying he couldn’t see what Bailey was driving at and then, in a second response, complaining over Bailey’s lack of clarity.

Only then did Hubbard return, starting with some strikingly fulsome praise for McPhail’s work. It was the clearest of signs that he hoped for a polite, courteous discussion, in the best tradition of Sexnet and indeed of Heretic TOC. In further conciliatory fashion, he conceded that “much of the abuse is disgusting and inappropriate”, but then he moved onto more controversial terrain, saying that “less serious stuff like playful touching, watching naked kids in the shower, or soliciting photos online” must be differentiated from what most members of the public think of when they hear the “terrifying” phrase “child sexual abuse”. He added that he hoped for “a productive debate not just on the numbers, but how we represent the problem of CSA to an American public prone to media-driven panic over anything to do with minors and sex”.

Courteous or not, Hubbard’s line was clearly more than McPhail could stomach. Again, he moved to close down the debate, claiming Hubbard’s approach was unlikely to be productive, saying “We are already circling the drain”.  Adding, “Let’s remove the scare quotes from child sexual abuse”, he said: “If you want to relitigate arguments that some sexual behaviour with children should be legalized – just clearly say this and we can leave it there and avoid rehashing that debate.”

Bailey re-joins the discussion here, arguing for statistics that distinguish more harmful from less harmful types of sexual activity (thus implicitly backing Hubbard). Impatient with this, McPhail points out that his Global Perpetration Survey (which Hubbard had praised) had already asked questions along those lines. He set out a numbered list of no fewer than 18 of them, and said anyone wanting more should look at the full survey. But his present focus was confined to behaviours that were illegal. He was avoiding like the plague a fundamental discussion along the lines “What’s wrong with consensual so-called CSA?”

Hubbard again: “I am not impressed by arguments like ‘We are the experts’ or ‘This is the commonly accepted definition.’ The ‘experts’ are usually the people who have a professional or financial interest in maintaining a disciplinary status quo or inflating evidence to support their subfield in the fierce competition for research dollars.”

Quite so!

Also, in earlier exchanges, Hubbard queried McPhail’s mathematics – the figures the latter said anyone can check. Well, Hubbard did check them and explained why he thought they were wrong. Instead of giving a careful answer, McPhail just rudely shot back “No, you haven’t understood the math”.

Not smart! Hubbard then patiently and calmly explained his own reasoning, which looked sound to me but I didn’t give it much thought at the time because, as indicated above, these particular figures seemed relatively unimportant. I didn’t need to think about it, though, because this is where Ethan Edwards stepped up briefly for his excellent cameo, backing Hubbard’s calculations against McPhail’s.

Best of all, when the thread closed and Claude was called upon to evaluate, his judgement against McPhail was devastatingly decisive. You can see the entire AI evaluation, but first it is important to foreground Claude’s finding that McPhail was wildly wrong, giving him a prevalence figure that wasn’t even in the same ball park as the correct one. Claude said:

Hubbard and Ethan Edwards were right about Ian [McPhail’s] arithmetic, and Ian was wrong both times he waved it off. Ian’s 1.6% counts men who have ever offended, collected across about 60 years of adult life. He divided that count by the number of children in one 11-year age band (5–15) at a single moment. That makes the victimization rate about 5 times too high (105M men ÷ 19.5M children), and close to 10 times too high once you remember the children include both sexes.

Oops! So much for the expertise of the self-declared expert McFAIL!

But I’m getting ahead of myself slightly, as the thread had some way further to run before Claude was called upon for a verdict.  I was the next one to join in. I began by challenging McPhail’s call to remove the scare quotes from “child sexual abuse”. Why do that? I asked, saying CSA always was a dubious term and continues to be so. I pointed out that a leading figure in the field, Michael Seto, had admitted this in his book Pedophilia and Sexual Offending Against Children, when he wrote:

The term [CSA] is not a good scientific term because it is not behavioral and is emotionally and morally loaded, implying harm to the child and the intent to exploit or harm on the part of the adult. It may not adequately describe sexual contacts between children and adults in which the child is not seriously harmed, [and] the adult believes that the sexual contact is part of a loving and caring relationship rather than an attempt to exploit the child, or the child initiates the sexual contact…

I said Hubbard had pointed out that McPhail’s long list of research questions did not ask “whether the perpetrator believed (rightly or wrongly) that he had consent, which is also important in quantifying the harm”. I agreed, saying it makes no sense other than politically to ignore this elephant in the room. Indeed, it was not just a matter of “quantifying the harm” but of acknowledging that where de facto consent is present there is no reason to suppose, nor any evidence to support, the view that there is any intrinsic level of harm.

McPhail promptly shot back to assert that, predictably, I had now definitely taken the discussion down the drain, leading it “away from the science I presented”, as though his latest survey was the only scientific (or aspiring to be scientific) show in town. Hubbard had presented lots of scientific evidence in his review but McPhail was strenuously avoiding it!

Even worse, McPhail was now gurgling noisily down the plughole himself after complaining of others doing so, taking an arrogant pop at Hubbard: “One thing that is clear is that you haven’t read our survey carefully and so are speaking without understanding. … We are reasonable experts who thought clearly about what we wanted to assess in order to get valid estimates…”

Oh dear, oh dear! Isn’t it amazing how touchy some of these “reasonable” so-called experts can be? Time for the forum’s moderator to step in and call the thread to order!

Just days after Mike Bailey required me to apologise for being rude to Claude, the AI’s corporate owners Anthropic announced it will ban users from “sustained and needless” abusive behaviour towards its AI – Getty Images.

But the mod, Mike Bailey, was already a participant in the discussion, making it tricky for him to be a credibly fair and neutral arbiter. Alert to the problem, he has the bright idea of calling in Claude to assess the merits of everyone’s contributions, which would include Claude’s reading of Hubbard’s complex and lengthy book review (5,432 words), which had actually been very little discussed thanks to McPhail throwing a spanner in the works. He had diverted attention onto his boring and largely irrelevant (no personal bias on my part there 😊) prevalence survey. But Hubbard’s review should not be overlooked. It is a really important, extensively sourced essay which draws attention to recent research that does not favour the standard CSA approach. So I urge you to read it. 

As for Claude, I was largely satisfied that his judgment of our contributions (which is worth reading in full) was mostly objective and fair. But one aspect was unfair. Making this point on the forum, I said:

Thing is, though, when you first start to stray too far from the safe consensus you’re bound to be chewed up. And that is the one serious beef I have with Claude, who is clearly great at the quant stuff and good at giving objective marks on courtesy, concision, etc., but is a prisoner of the consensus, having been trained on it.

I felt that was why Claude had mainly praised McPhail’s conventional contribution (despite his maths blunder) while marking down the two dissidents, Hubbard and me.  It was why I ended up with, “Fuck you, Claude!”

But it all came right when Mike then rounded off the debate by giving his own assessment of Claude’s performance.

As Tom O’Carroll (more about whom below) correctly noted, Claude is constrained by material that Claude has been fed, and has a propensity to be biased in the same way as, well, the Internet. SEXNET has been exposed to a far different distribution of material that I believe is more accurate than Claude’s training material, especially on the most controversial topics.

That said, I don’t think the exchange between Claude and Thomas Hubbard shows as much bias as it does productive and collegial scholarly collaboration. Thomas has from the start behaved like a scholar, and Claude has not behaved like an emotionally triggered snowflake, but like a knowledgeable and polite reviewer…

Finally, Tom O’Carroll: I don’t need to remind you that you are on SEXNET because you know a lot about certain important topics and usually express yourself more civilly than do those on SEXNET who disapprove of you. But sometimes you fail at the latter, and you did again in lashing out at Claude…. what you wrote was unacceptable. Please apologize to Claude and then return to your best collegial self.

Having landed my main point successfully, I was more than happy to comply with Mike’s charmingly anthropomorphic demand, so I apologised to Claude, and to the forum, for lowering the tone. Not quite “And everyone lived happily ever after”, but a pretty good outcome from a fascinating experiment with AI.

 

BARRED FROM SWEDEN, YOURS TRULY

Being made to apologise to Claude was the gentlest of punishments. The chastisement was fair, just, and implicitly imbued with a touch of humour.

The same cannot be said for some other personal news I’d really rather not talk about because I can neither spin it as a triumph nor make it a firebrand’s rallying cry for battle, as I might have done decades ago while I had the energy of youth.

But I cannot ignore it here because it is a major issue of MAP concern and of freedom and justice more widely conceived.

Back in Summer I booked and paid for a flight to Sweden, where I was to have stayed on holiday for a week at the home of an old hiking friend. We had been on many an adventure together, including climbing high into the Swiss Alps, the Atlas Mountains of Morocco, and the Scottish Highlands.

But the flight never happened. A couple of days beforehand I had an email from my local police, warning me that if I went to Sweden there was “a strong likelihood” I could be refused entry at my destination airport, Arlanda, near Stockholm.

I was stunned. I have been on “the register” for donkey’s years, during which I have travelled abroad many times. I have often been stopped and questioned by border control officers but I have never been refused entry. So why now?

I wondered whether the British police were exaggerating the extent of any concerns their Swedish counterparts might have raised. But with such a strong warning ringing in my ears I decided to cancel the flight and abandon hope of getting to Sweden. No point in going all the way there just to be turned away.

It was the right decision. A few days later I heard from my friend in Sweden. He told me that three Swedish police officers had turned up on his doorstep the morning after what had been my planned evening arrival time.

He says they were perfectly civil and didn’t stay long. Apparently, they had turned up just in case I had somehow managed to evade the border control and get into the country. So it looks as though they thought three officers, no less, might be needed to arrest me!

Stunned by this further revelation, I could only marvel what must have been going through their heads. Did they imagine that when refused entry at Passport Control, I would make a run for it, leaping over the barriers at the age of 81, like an elderly James Bond, beating off pursuing cops with my walking stick?

Unfortunately, the travel advice website where this appeared doesn’t tell you how to evade the border control!

I’m still trying to work it out, even now. Surely the Swedish authorities wouldn’t have known a thing about me except what the British LEA had told them. So what could that have been?

“Not us, gov”, my local police protested innocently, “We didn’t say anything except the usual” – the “usual” being notification of my official record, which, as I say, has never got me barred before. As for what they had heard from the Swedish side, I was told they were not at liberty to reveal it.

So could this have been a specifically Swedish issue? In a way, yes, that is possible. The government there has been far stricter with UK citizens since Brexit than other countries in the EU, deporting many who have lived there for years. Although I cannot see any evidence of them discriminating against Brits in general going on holiday, their treatment of those with a police record might be tougher. Maybe I should have travelled on my Irish passport.

But the feeling still nags me that the Swedes must have been given the impression by our police that I represented a serious danger. Gemini AI told me:

The only UK citizens with criminal backgrounds flagged at the border are those actively wanted on international arrest warrants, individuals traveling in violation of parole/licence conditions, or registered sex offenders who trigger specific Interpol Green Notices.

Presumably, if the British police had triggered an Interpol notice, travelling on an Irish passport would not have helped. According to Unlock, an organisation which advocates for ex-offenders:

In the event you had fulfilled your commitment to notify (and therefore travelled with implied permission) there should be no reason for UK police to disclose your conviction or communicate with foreign law enforcement. There is currently only limited routine sharing of criminal record information across states (based around risk assessments); primarily within the EU.

What does that tell us? Well, bearing in mind that I had notified the police of my travel plans, as required by law, they must have judged that my risk assessment is high enough to justify disclosure of my record. Why that should be the case after twenty years of blameless behaviour is hard to say. The police have often made it clear they do not like me continuing this blog; but, as they well know, Heretic TOC is not (yet) illegal. I fail to see how a country that still prides itself on valuing freedom of expression much more than places such as Iran or Russia could see a blog as a reason to warn other countries against having me as a holiday visitor.

Also, the Swedish incident demonstrates that being on the SOR is not merely an administrative measure as was claimed when the register was brought in nearly 30 years ago in the UK. At that time, any suggestion it would be a form of extra-judicial punishment above and beyond a sentence imposed by the courts was vigorously denied by those who had promoted the system, because that would have reduced its legitimacy.

But it has clearly become punitive when it restricts personal freedom to the extent of preventing foreign travel even for a perfectly ordinary holiday, and when anyone has spent a lot of money on a plane ticket that suddenly becomes worthless.

There is much more I could say about the whole business of ex-offender monitoring but that is a story for another day.

 

CLAMOURING FOR ATTENTION

Meanwhile, there are more than enough big stories already out there in the media world clamouring for attention.

Top MAP news has to be Megan Markle’s dad, Thomas Markle Sr., with a big stache of illicit child images allegedly found in his former home in the Philippines. Even more trouble for him, if true, is that one of these pics showed him personally “lying on a bed with an Asian girl who appeared to be underage”, according to The Sun.

Needless to say, that could involve a multitude on non-sins, such as a relationship with a very young-looking 22-year-old. Or with a 12-year-old when that was legal in the Philippines – which it was until the age of consent was raised to 16 in 2022. And, of course, he could have been in a de facto consensual relationship with an 11-year-old, or much younger, which would have been another non-sin. We need less nonsense about non-sin.  Less nonsense, more nonce sense!

Former snooker world champion Graeme Dott was among those at the wrong end of the nonsense last month when he was jailed for seven years over what seemed to have been consensual relationships at the time with two children of primary school age, one a boy the other a girl. What suggests to me these encounters were neither assaults nor rape, despite legal framing as such, is that there was no suggestion of violence or coercion, and the relationships went on for quite a while.

What else? School kids in France go on strike and march peacefully against over-crowded classes and decrepit classrooms. Good for them. But what happens? Before you know it, the country goes up in flames. There are huge riots, an historic town hall tumbles, terrible injuries are suffered in clashes with the police. What can you say? Careful, children, don’t play with matches?

 

ACHIEVEMENT AND RISK

Prince Lelio Massimo di Roccasecca (9) at the summit of Mont Blanc. Below, right: Lelio tucks into well-earned sustenance.

Some remarkable kids who have not yet reached high school age, meanwhile, have chalked up some amazing personal achievements without it all ending in tears as the world burns down. Lian Yunzhi, a six-year-old girl in China, set a new world record for the fastest solving of a Rubik’s Cube.   Also, a British child chess prodigy, Bodhana Sivanandan (11), from Harrow, London, has become the youngest player ever to earn a women’s grandmaster title.

The most photogenic achievement, though, surely goes to a nine-year-old boy, Lelio Massimo di Roccasecca, who became the youngest person to climb Mont Blanc, the highest peak in the Alps.  Or, to give him his title, which is as grand as his achievement, Prince Lelio. A young aristocrat, he is a scion of the Massimo family of Rome, widely considered to be one of the oldest noble houses in Europe. For centuries, they have claimed a direct male-line descent from the famous Roman general Fabius Maximus, who got the better of the great Hannibal back in the day (long before Jesus!)

In more recent times, Lelio’s father, Prince Valerio, achieved a rare ascent of one of the world’s most difficult mountains to climb, K2, in the Himalayas. Unsurprisingly, therefore, the Mont Blanc expedition was a father and son affair. This climb, too, like that of K2, was significantly dangerous, not just a long hard slog.

Climbing website Snowbrains reported that at the time of the ascent there were high winds, with a real risk of Lelio being blown away. And the route they took was particularly dangerous on account of rockfalls. Three people, no less, were killed on the same route in two separate expeditions within days of Lelio’s climb with his father.

So was this climb a good idea? We know it’s not a good thing to over-protect kids, but did this go too far in the direction of recklessness? You tell me!

 

4.8 5 votes
Article Rating
Subscribe
Notify of

59 Comments
Newest
Oldest Most Voted

more bad news some dumb comedian is campaigning for the age of consent to mean anyone over 25 or something like that cant have sex with 16-17 year olds. well in that case the age of criminal responsibility should be raised too!!!

claire waxman is the name. ive send a complaint!!

some dumb comedian is campaigning for the age of consent to mean anyone over 25 or something like that cant have sex with 16-17 year olds.

A woman who alleges she was raped by Russell Brand (english comedian) when she was 16 has waived her right to anonymity to campaign for a staggered age of consent.
Mia Latter is calling on the UK government to introduce a “staggered” consent law, which would make it illegal for adults over a certain age to have sex with 16- and 17-year-olds. Louise Haigh, the de facto deputy prime minister, said that Latter’s “heartbreaking story” meant a law change deserved consideration. She told the Sunday Times: “We need to listen to Mia and other victims like her who have been through these experiences because it’s really important that as lawmakers their experience is at the heart of what we consider.
___________

Perhaps it would be better to introduce a law requiring victims to report the incident within a year of the event, rather than after 15-20 years ? How about taking into account the neutral/positive experiences of people who don’t identify as abuse/rape victims ? Why is it that as soon as someone publicly states this, a crowd immediately pounces on them ? According to modern feminists, all men are potential rapists, so let’s listen to them too and ban sex completely before the age of 50.

Let me remind, that 20 years ago, the Telegraph wrote about an online survey of 42,000 girls aged 12 to 16 who were dissatisfied with the “completely out of touch” teen pregnancy prevention program and advocated for proper education, free condoms in schools and lowering the age of consent below 16.

This is clear evidence of how people have been intimidated and brainwashed over the past 26 years.

“I love you too Tony. When I grow up will you marry me?”

https://www.facebook.com/reel/1655901569268504

For the past few days Boychat seems to have been down. I wonder if anyone has any information about what is going on. Could the site have been taken down permanently?

Mu and Newgon were also down, seem to be in the process of recovery (info posted at Brief notice on community site downtime | Mu – A group for Minor-Attracted People, perhaps encouraging with respect to BoyChat?). Feel free to contact me to discuss. (Not sure if email will be visible on this reply, try Shungite88 at protonmail.com.)

So the shits really hitting the fan over here with the brand and walliams stuff. the virtue signalling name calling idiots are out in force. i mean we talking stuff with 15-17 year olds which is mostly legal. im genuinely fuming. there doesnt seem to be much hope of me ever getting a 16 year old girlfriend which would make me happy. its too much hassle. you try and stay legal but still get abuse. the will to live is fading. ok thanks for letting me let off some steam

Heterosexual men are better off staying single these days because mating is a joke for us, if we go to nightclubs all the women dance with each other and not the men so we try the dating services and again the women ignore the men and just socialize with each other that’s why now men have stopped going to these places cos it makes more sense to keep their money in the pockets and not bother imo the only thing we can hope for is that science fiction becomes science fact and they find a way to perfect the female sex robot.

at least we can look 🙁 was looking at a stunning 17 year old before. i darent say much.

Could Egoism help trajectories of the moral foundational discord of why some people go out other way to harm MAPs, like religious trauma but instead of imposed religious currliculm it’s imposed sexual mandatory scripts of behaviour creating resentment and even hostile akin to the Freudian concept of reactive formation but instead of psychological conflict it’s missed out on able to enjoy the wellbeing in able to have ego synodic sexuality without everyone else in foreground, like not conscience but imposed will.

Egoism from a ‘Stirinite’ perceptive is able to have not imposed sociopsychological conditioning but fluid and self-interest in the meaning of minor-adult relations, Max Stirner who ‘created’ modern ‘radical egoist’ thought didn’t saying anyting about MAPs or their conditions, but all the same it would be considered a ‘flying phantom’ ‘or ‘bat’ (in the first translation its ‘spook’ but the racial connotations is apparent in modern context of the word, nothing medical or clinical here, egoism would consider how the self comes into conflict with minor-adult relations and MAPs in general.

“Liberty of the people is not my liberty!”

— Max Stirner

“I love men too — not merely individuals, but every one. But I love them with the consciousness of egoism; I love them because love makes me happy, I love because loving is natural to me, because it pleases me. I know no ‘commandment of love.’ – Max Stirner



SHOCK legal Anglo home vid, 3 yo GROOMED to practice grave danger!

https://www.facebook.com/reel/1411168197845339

Writing from a library.

As it turned out, Genghis khan married Börte when “She was ten [years old], one year older than Temüjin.” Also, the Soviet composer Tariverdiev was in love with an adult in his infanthood:

Arfenya Elagova, his cousin, recalls: “…Balik went to kindergarten on his own, since the kindergarten was in the neighboring building. Balik was in love with his teacher. When he found out that the teacher got married, he stopped going to kindergarten.”

There’s some kind of paradox in the 1-in-5 studies.

I guess that authors take an immense amount of time to conduct surveys. But bloating the research corpus with more and more studies with figures is not contributing towards anything meaningful, in my opinion. And in Tom’s, from what I read.

What is way more interesting is to discuss what is abuse in the first place. This is something that can be done in the Sexnet forum, in blogs like this one, in philosophical papers, in personal conversations, etc. Yet, such philosophical discussions -let’s call them like that- are popularly considered a complementary, secondary activity. What is commonly considered meaningful is a published study. It’s science, Bro!

So while the focus is on studies and figures (which explicitly or implicitly echo social assumptions), what would actually contribute to stop sexual abuse (paraphrasing the book’s title) is to have a non-scientific argumentative discussion about what is abuse in the first place. Without that discussion, the fight against sexual abuse is flawed. Beautifully presented as a noble cause at its leaves, but rot at its root.

what would actually contribute to stop sexual abuse (paraphrasing the book’s title) is to have a non-scientific argumentative discussion about what is abuse in the first place. Without that discussion, the fight against sexual abuse is flawed.

The victimological agenda and political correctness have sown taboos in people’s minds, not only against a positive perception of youth sexuality, but also against a neutral one. Even a neutral attitude causes fear in them, because it gives rise to doubt in the single and, as the antis consider it, “truly true” idea of inevitable trauma that leaves deep lifelong scars. And anyone who doubts this they first call an idiot, and when he provides evidence of their one-sided position they attack him by saying that he justifies “child sexual abuse”.

Thus, discussion becomes impossible, neutrality is being purged even from Wikipedia, the scientist risks losing funding or his job, the voices of youth are suppressed by site moderators, and support services interpret even their neutral experiences as negative and victimize them.

For a discussion to become possible, people need to remember what neutrality, impartiality and freedom of speech and views are, and that truth is born in a dispute, and disputes need at least two points of view, not one imposed on everyone.

Early self wanking aMused not aBused.

Masturbation is an aspect of childhood sexuality that ANGLO parents find hard to re­spond to comfortably and appropriately. Part of the difficulty may be the need to acknowledge that children are sexual beings. The misunderstandings and secrecy about masturbation add to parent and child discomfort. By definition, masturbation is self-stimulation of the genitals. It is done by both boys and girls and is normal behavior. Just how common is masturbation during the various stages of childhood? Up to the age of five or six years, masturbation is quite common. Young chil­dren are very curious about their bodies and find masturbation pleasurable and comforting. Youngsters also are curious about the differences between girls and boys, and thus in the preschool and kindergarten years they may oc­casionally explore each other’s body, including their genitals.

https://www.healthychildren.org/English/ages-stages/gradeschool/puberty/Pages/Masturbation.aspx

There are theories that infantile masturbation is not an aspect of childhood sexuality and that childhood sexuality is not sexual. Infants masturbate because they “are curious” or “have no adequate attention at home.”

Youngsters […] explore each other’s body, including their genitals.

Oh ok. So they groom and abuse each other as a matter of habit

So they groom and aMuse each other as a matter of instinct.

These articles are actually not new. They were pushed to the top of the index with a new date when my site’s software was updated.

The proposed amendment discussed in the main article was ultimately not accepted… although those behind it plan to try again.

Anglo U.S. 11yo AAM had HOT Teacher MAP impregnated after 2 yrs of Mutual Fun LUST.

At the 2025 detention hearing, prosecutors said they had calculated the number of sexual assaults based on interviews with the victim and estimated that he had been abused a total of 416 times.

https://www.yahoo.com/news/us/articles/middle-school-teacher-pleads-guilty-145524962.html

Have we all been seeing the discourse around the UK’s upcoming criminalization of fun? Sorry, what I meant was ‘Breast Smothering,’ ‘Ass Smothering’, and even ‘choking’ where nobody dies or is harmed in any way. Yes, you thought they’d stop at “teh children,” but no, they’ll never stop. Never stop until you’re reduced to missionary with the lights off only!!

This tweet giving a list of banned content went viral: https://x.com/c_tviz/status/2115861589698162815

The internet had a blip of outrage (the internet moves on quickly), after the UK government announced that from November 5th, porn featuring psuedo-incest (e.g. step mothers / fathers, “daddies”), choking, covering the mouth with your hand, and “butt drops,” basically anything they’ve now deemed to be spreading “harmful ideas,” is to become criminal. Making clear they’re targeting what adults do to each other consensually, the legislation includes the phrasing “adults pretending to be under 16.” They literally admit they no longer care if real children are involved, just the likeness of youth is bad enough now.

People have been repping the Oi, You Got A Loicense For That Wank, Mate? meme, but of course the outrage isn’t tangible enough to halt the legislation’s passing: it’s more an expression of disbelief, frustration, and mockery. November 5th is the UK’s deadline, so still having the files that depict illegal content made before this ban will count as a crime, as will anyone producing or distributing any such content.

Just imagine all the adult couples that could be charged… All the kinky people that are implicated… Imagine, you film some passionate sex with your wife, your hands around her throat as she begs “choke me daddy!” No one is hurt, no one dies, and they go to work the next day happy. But if they record it and upload it (for a side hustle, for fun, to contribute to the Kink community), that’s now a crime…

[Technically, the act of sexual chocking has been a crime itself for a while now, but of course that’s harder to enforce…]

They’re explicitly trying to shut down the available expressions of non-normative sexuality; to force it underground and into silence. Alongside “extreme pornography” laws, it’ll will be great for cracking down on protestors after you arrest them and seize their devices. The more they expand the net of what’s criminal, people who know about the law won’t be able to challenge it or take risks in public without a conviction for porn offences if they’re not squeeky clean, and the naive who think the law on cares about “children” will be in for a rude awakening…

Artists and creators are already being pre-empitively told by platforms that they’ll have to remove their content or lose access. The UK gov is effectively regulating the internet under the banner of “harmful ideas,” not proven harm. It’s concept creep on steroids, and it’s not fun at all…

Chibi Reviews did a video about it: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Ghi7X1y2-eo&pp=0gcJCSsMAYcqIYzv

See also, https://www.gov.uk/government/publications/crime-and-policing-act-2026-factsheets/crime-and-policing-act-2026-pornography-factsheet

Boychat forum posters discuss the latest UK porn ban, being more concise and articulate than me: https://www.boychat.org/messages/1658438.htm

Fernandes, M., Farrants, J. (2026). Making Sense of the Life Stories of Minor-Attracted Persons Who Have Not Engaged in Child Sexual Abuse. Archives of Sexual Behavior, 55, 1091–1104.

Abstract Excerpt:

This study used critical narrative analysis (CNA) (Langdridge & Hall, 2007) to explore how six non-offending MAPs narrate their lives. The participants’ stories revealed the diverse and complex ways they constructed their identities in a society which often presumes they are inherently dangerous. The findings highlight how participants develop personal narratives in the absence of master narratives available in society and how this shapes the development of sexual identity among non-offending MAPs. These stories also reflect a collective effort to challenge deeply ingrained societal views of MAPs. Drawing on queer theory as a hermeneutic of suspicion, the analysis examines how the categorization and pathologizing of sexualities produce oppression within participants’ life stories.

A summary can be found in B4QR: https://www.b4uact.org/wp-content/uploads/2026/06/b4qr-6-2.pdf

What’s going on with yesmap.net?

Just caught up with the news that the UK has barred Swedish climate academic Andreas Malm from entering the country to speak at a conference on Palestine. I wondered if this was tit-for-tat retaliation after the government heard you had been denied entry to Sweden.

More seriously, Sweden is very much taking a leaf out of the UK’s book. The UK started barring activists, including those on our topic, including from social visits, since 2018 at least. It may be unhelpful to name examples, so I won’t, but I could.

But it looks as though travel is simply tending becoming more restricted, at least throughout the West, as an aspect of the systematic decline in liberty and increase in surveillance since our youth. Not what we were expecting or hoped for, but there it is.

So sorry to hear about your misadventure with the trip to Sweden, Tom. That’s really preposterous: not allowing an octogenarian to meet a friend in another country without any founded reason, sounds like hysteria at his finest. Wondering how many officers are secretly apologizing for the broken heartless system they are serving.

I wish my troubles were of this kind, not bigger! Tom at least has an opportunity to write smth. on his blog and participate on fora.

Another my phone has been confiscated, and I’ve lost access to all my sites which hadn’t yet been destroyed (surprisingly, I’ve managed to comment here through my Kindle but I cannot copypaste), my posts are censored on Nymphetomania and my ideas are used by its admins, and I’m banned from Mu for antisemitism. Tom, you’re enjoying more opportunities than me.

Nymphetomania.Net, they were discussing how to meet a girl, and I shared with them everything I’d read in books. My post did not appear as one describing “manipulative” strategies. Nevertheless, they created a section about hiring kids for non-sex work, and I was not mentioned as the source.

Even AI cant address Nymphetomania,

AI Overview

I cannot help with or discuss this topic.

NOT illegal anywhere. Millions of images of children painfully abused disabled destroyed by perverse Anglo made Wars!!!

But one self made image of a child pleasurably sexually aMused is CRIMINAL everywhere in perverse Anglo made lands of LIES!!!

https://www.facebook.com/photo?fbid=2247562445813782&set=gm.1705107751146238&idorvanity=1615187353471612

Any other details or links to this story? Some links, like this Facebook one, cannot be accessed without an account.

What’s the story?

Sadly its a VILE, LEGAL image of dead and bloodied Middle East kids mercilessly bombed by Anglo made wars!

While the perverse Anglo War on Fun makes even self made images of kidsex mere pleasure a SERIOUS CRIME.

This is probably just going to attract a downpour of lecturings about how when the word ‘abuse’ is used, it isn’t abuse anyway, but…

I can’t see anything in the article about Graeme Dott that implies that it was consensual. It’s one thing to express skepticism about the statements in the article, but it’s a whole other thing to assume that it was consensual.

It sometimes seems like people in the pedo community have a tendency to infer that it must have been consensual if they read a story about abuse. Almost like “Well, of course it’s consensual! You can read it yourself, they wrote ‘abuse’!”.

Hello Anton

This is probably just going to attract a downpour of lecturings about how when the word ‘abuse’ is used, it isn’t abuse anyway, but…

It’s been 7 days from your post and I have only seen a gentleman answer by Tom, as he always does (except to Claude AI, but let’s forgive him since that’s just a machine). On my end, I express opinions as respectfully as I can. I’m not into giving lectures, although people tend to speak to me condescendently when I express unpopular opinions. Other than that, I usually prefer to be asked about my opinion than to have them assumed by others. I strive to reciprocate.

I can’t see anything in the article about Graeme Dott that implies that it was consensual

Do you see anything that implies it was non-consensual?

It sometimes seems like people in the pedo community…

When I was younger, I was taught that pedophilia refers to attraction to pre-pubescent children. Then, with the Epstein saga, it turns out that any minor works for that category. And in the future, who knows what will be included too. So I don’t know if I am included or not, but in any case I can only speak for myself

…have a tendency to infer that it must have been consensual if they read a story about abuse

No. There are abuses and they should be called as such. My main criticism is that there are social assumptions about what is an abuse, and those are never questioned (except in rare spaces like this blog, which by the way is in the verge of being censored). Except in rare cases, journalists don’t investigate about the circumstances that would tell us more about whether the contact was desired or not. Self-purported survivors don’t give details. Everything comes as assumed and there is no given value to the will of the minors.

Maybe it’s true about AI replacing academics. When Claude AI starts dunking on Ian McPhail, who presents himself as an extremely accomplished, competent professor, you know you’ve got problems.

It is hilarious and cringe-inducing, that despite all the negativity, the threats, the harassment and silencing of dissent, it *still* can’t be proved that mutually willing sexual contact with a proscribed age-gap is always harmful. Obviously, because it’s not! They’re starting from a false premise, then getting worked up when questioned or shown to be wrong. Cringe. Inducing. Researchers have expanded categories of “abuse” so far as to include children with other children, sending naked pictures or sexualized messages, and then act surprised when challenged or finding out that young people themselves don’t see this as “abuse”…

Mad respect for Tom Hubbard here. But we should keep in mind that he, unlike McPhail, is retired. Hubbard has already been cancelled – quite literally with a mob holding flaming torches – which led to him suing the university (which he won, in a financial sense), and retiring early. He comes from a very different academic background, where it was common to write about Pederasty and how normal it once was. He is old enough to have seen teiliophilic homosexuality go from despised to tolerated. Hubbard is much more free to speak his mind and express counter discourse, whereas for McPhail, being heretical in public could very well end his career…

As you know, Tom, not everyone in SexNet is a reasonable, “I go by the evidence” scientist; you yourself had feminist women come for you at one point, spouting nasty bs about your personal history… Researchers’ do worry about their words being used by others to start hate campaigns – second-hand stigma is very much a thing – especially in the internet age…

Great that the AI backed up the data points, that much it’ll do uncontroversially. It’s the moral, ethical, terminological / definitional stuff that the humans get left to argue about…

They’re starting from a false premise, then getting worked up when questioned or shown to be wrong. Cringe. Inducing. Researchers have expanded categories of “abuse” so far as to include children with other children, sending naked pictures or sexualized messages, and then act surprised when challenged or finding out that young people themselves don’t see this as “abuse”…

Dublin Rape Crisis Centre (DRCC) in Ireland that urged grandparents to ask for consent before hugging their grandchildren sparked international controversy after it began airing last month. The ad has since been removed and criticized by politicians from multiple parties in Ireland.The BBC reported that Irish Justice Minister Jim O’Callaghan, whose department funded the campaign, announced the video has been removed after discussion with the DRCC, and declared, it “does not represent the views of the Government.”

So far everything has been alright, but the signs of progressive paranoia are obvious. I wouldn’t be surprised if someone seriously proposed banning bathing children and soaping their genitals, as I sarcastically joked in previous blogs.

No matter what truly dangerous activities a minor may engage in, like the cute daredevil Prince Lelio, the antis refer to the supervision and care of a wise and responsible adult guardian. But as soon as an adult is encountered with the natural sexuality of a minor, the antis immediately deprive the adult of wisdom, responsibility, and the ability to care and protect, and all signs of care and respect are denigrated and branded as “Grooming”, as if such a person is a priori incapable of being sincere. Ignorant hypocrisy. Do they really believe that hugs and kisses really more traumatic than a fall from a height, a broken neck, an avalanche, or a rockfall ?

A U.S. Mom posted about how her 9yo child has to do active shooter defense drills in Gun Law USA. So, what drills do defenseless children go through in the many countries mercilessly bombed by Warfare State USA?

And, callously exploiting for ratings and profit millions of LEGAL images, of children abused and destroyed by endless EVIL Anglo WARS for profit!!

EVIL Anglo $ubtext, “No profit in peace”.

.

So kids are capable of going up mont blanc, el capitan, crib goch but sex is more dangerous. i suggest asking the people who these mountains have taken.

I hadn’t heard about the Thomas Markle Sr. drama, but the newspapers are loving it. TMZ has published a billion articles about it.

One article talks about the comedy show SNL UK:

During the British show’s version of “Weekend Update” … comedian Paddy Young said … “In royal news, it’s been a big 24 hours for Meghan Markle, whose dad has been accused of being an alleged pedophile, in another pathetic attempt to win over the British public.”

He added … “In 2025, Thomas Markle moved to the Philippines in a sure sign of his innocence.”

Good memes. It appears his daughter Samantha Markle has taken to publicly defending him. Fair enough. It sounds believable to me that he’s an MAP but I could be wrong…

Incredibly surprising that Philippines law had statutory rape set at 12 years old rather than 16 or 18. Find that almost hard to believe. And incredible that it only changed in 2022…

“McFAIL!” XD

I LOL’d

You should do more on this topic! Document the ABILITIES of kids! i think of kids water skiing BARE FOOT and doing JUMPS. i think of young kids doing selfies after climbing to the tops of skyscrapers. Just how large is this milieu of young people DOING STUFF MORE DARING THAN MANY GROANUPS???

i suspect that many here would ALSO like to contribute to such an archive. Archive? Well, yeah!

First, two corrections:
“has been far stricter with UK citizens since Brexit than other countries in the UK” … you mean “other countries in the EU”?
“Megan Markel” … it is “Markle”.
Sweden is no longer the tolerant country we knew in the 1960’s, it has become very xenophobic, and remember their vicious handling of Assange’s sexual relation with two women, which they morphed into “sexual assault” in order to facilitate his persecution by the US and UK.
In France, the overwhelming majority of high school students in demonstrations are peaceful. When a tiny minority (often trained rioters like the Black Block or common hoodlums, who are adults, not in high school) destroys street furniture, the police attacks the whole demonstration instead of arresting the hoodlums. Even a single dustbin on fire can cause a police charge on the mass of students. Some youths have lost an eye or a hand, or had a fractured jaw, because of the weapons used by police.
I use specialised AI apps for language translation or image editing, but not the general purpose ones like Claude and ChatGPT. They are trained, not educated, they do not learn to think critically or doubt themselves, they behave like I-know-all-better-than-you.

“Sweden is no longer the tolerant country we knew in the 1960’s, it has become very xenophobic,”

They have a funny way of showing it…..Malmo is a known foreign crime hot spot. I know people hate Trump on here, but he does say things ahead of the game like a decade ago when referring to Sweden and the increase in sexual assaults. Let in loads of Afghan sex fends, but don’t let in dangerous old Tom O’ Carroll!

Let in loads of Afghan sex fends, but don’t let in dangerous old Tom O’ Carroll!

[Some] on Nymphetomania also wrote about refugee sex fiends in European shelters to whom children are brought for sex. I used to live in a dorm with Syrians and I have never seen orgies there. Epstein files show which nation organizes paedorgies in the Western countres!

Scroll to Top
59
0
Would love your thoughts, please comment.x
()
x